Best American Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

View all

Best American Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(801)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
Tavern on the Green
(2668)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(387)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Sheepshead Bay restaurants

  • Restaurant List
  • Best restaurants

Sheepshead Bay Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Sheepshead Bay restaurants

Sheepshead Bay Restaurants

Nargis Cafe
Nargis Cafe
(26)
Middle Eastern | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was excellent the decor pleasing and the service good BUT: the main courses should have been served all together instead of one of us eating while the others just watched. This was disturbing. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tsob-Tsobe
Tsob-Tsobe
(11)
Mediterranean | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

I really enjoyed the food and the service and I definitely recommend to others More

OpenTable Diner -
Anthony's Place
Anthony's Place
(114)
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

See all offers

First time trying Anthony’s. Went on a Friday and they had great happy hour specials. Discounted drinks and appetizers. We had the red sangria which was excellent. We ordered the buffalo calamari, shrimp Oreganata and mussels. Also ordered baked clams from regular menu. Everything was great but the winner was the shrimp! Kelley, our waitress, was great. She was attentive and gave us great recommendations. We were full but ordered the veal chop for dinner and the chopped salad (Bobb salad) to share and the other person had the lasagne. The salad was light and delicious! I tasted the lasagne which I thought was great. The veal chop was a little on the tough side but had great flavor. The chef stopped by the table to see how everything was and gave us a taste of the homemade wine he makes on the house. So good!! Dessert was his homemade Italian cheesecake which was delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Next Door
Next Door
(42)
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was incredible! The staff were welcoming and friendly. Overall, great dining experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
(16)
Sushi | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Outstanding!! More

OpenTable Diner -
Il Fornetto
Il Fornetto
(207)
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

I wanted a very scenic place with great food and excellent service as my long time friend was coming in to visit from Connecticut. She also wanted a fresh seafood option. Il Fornetto totally fits the bill! We had the fish of the day and a salad. Shared both and portion size was adequate. The fish came garnished with two large wedges of roasted potatoes which were excellent. The arugula salad was fresh and full of pistachios, goat cheese and perfectly dressed. I would definitely come back with company again! More

OpenTable Diner -
Blu Turkish Restaurant
Blu Turkish Restaurant
(50)
Turkish | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Excellent food and service. Highly recommend! More

OpenTable Diner -
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
(86)
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Nice and clean and very tasty More

OpenTable Diner -
Passage Restaurant NYC
Passage Restaurant NYC
Reviews coming soon
European | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Modern Euvropean Restaurant located on Emmons ave. in Brooklyn with Beautiful veiw on Water, we provide A La Carte and Banquet menu with Shows on Weekends, also serving private parties and catering. Check our website www.passagenyc.com or give us a call for more information 1 (718) 368 3434More

Affecte Cafe & Lounge
Affecte Cafe & Lounge
Reviews coming soon
Mediterranean | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

INNOVATING FOR A GLOBAL PALATE SINCE 1987.

Born into our big multicultural family, AFFECTÉ is an eclectic café lounge with a passion for unique experiences. We have fused the best of contemporary Middle Eastern and European cultures with New York City attitude to create an eyeopening experience. Guests can indulge in dishes ranging from traditional Sultan’s kebab plate and filet mignon to hand chopped and hand pressed burgers. We proudly make each and every dish on the menu from scratch to match our standards of perfection. The hookah program showcases an extended flavor profile to satisfy any cravings. Whether part of a big party or a dinner for two, we are excited to be part of it and make your experience unforgettable.More

Liman Restaurant
Liman Restaurant
(8)
Turkish | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Early Mother's Day dinner. I've been going to Liman for many years and the place always delivers. Amazing hospitality and delicious food. Highly recommend their Royal Dorado fish! More

OpenTable Diner -
Kennedy's Restaurant
Kennedy's Restaurant
(1)
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The buffet is amazing so many options to choose from SO MUCH FOOD!!!! More

OpenTable Diner -
John's Luncheonette
John's Luncheonette
Reviews coming soon
Central Asian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Kan Wah Restaurant
Kan Wah Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
Chinese | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Clemente's Maryland Crab House
Clemente's Maryland Crab House
Reviews coming soon
Seafood | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

For high-quality seafood in Brooklyn NY, visit Clemente's Maryland Crab House. Located in scenic Sheepshead Bay close to the eastern edge of the world renowned Coney Island, this highly popular restaurant has been recently renovated. Clemente's Maryland Crab House has been offering delicious world class food, service, events catering, daily specials and entertainment since 2002 and is a choice destination for tourists, locals and people looking for a great cocktail at happy hour.

The impressive menu offers something for everyone with fresh food served in a casual dining area or on the bayside patio. The restaurant is complete with a full-service Tiki Bar and lounge overlooking the picture-perfect Venice Marina. Come in for the special catch or the all-you-can-eat Crab on Mondays and Tuesdays. Clemente's Maryland Crab House is a gem and a wonderful place to bring friends or family.

More

Jordan's Lobster Dock
Jordan's Lobster Dock
Reviews coming soon
Seafood | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Jordan's Lobster Dock serves up some very fresh seafood and has outdoor seating when the weather permits. There is also beer and wine available for those of age. The venue is great for kids and larger groups. Jordan's Lobster Dock is open for business every day from morning until late night.

The menu at Jordan's Lobster Dock is incredibly extensive. The homemade chowders and bisque are creamy and full of shellfish. Those who love fried foods should be sure to check out the calamari or the fried shrimp. Customers who are interested in non-seafood options can order everything from hot dogs and hamburgers to wings and chicken fingers. The pastas are very filling and can be topped with white or red clam sauce. There are even tasty desserts like key lime pie and cheesecake.

More

OPM Restaurant
OPM Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
Asian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

OPM Restaurant is an Asian-fusion restaurant and dance club. The trendy and casual restaurant has a restriction of guests above 21 years only. It has an indoor fine-die seating arrangement. The bar has high chairs and stools. The dining room is decorated with small red-colored fairy lights. The outdoor seating area is designated for musical nights, barbecue fire grills on weekends and smoking. OPM Restaurant and Ultra Lounge has a soundproof music room, brightly-lit with vibrant disco lights. Krisha is the outdoor seating area with café-style furniture. It is used for celebrations and parties. It offers a nice view of Emmons Ave sunset over the bay.

OPM Restaurant and Ultra Lounge serves a variety of barbecue cuisines from all around the world. Lamb kebobs are served with Lebanese hummus. The cabbage salad is served in thick creamy sauce and cherry tomatoes.

More

Old Castle
Old Castle
Reviews coming soon
European | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Old Castle is a pub and a restaurant inspired by Irish culture and experience. The waiters serve with charm and hospitality. Old Castle is located on two floors. There are big screens installed making it a nice place to watch the big games with food and drinks. The restaurant also has live music on the weekends. It�s a good place to hang out and relax with your friends with some snacks and drinks.

Old Castle is popularly known for its reasonable drinks. Popular dishes in the menu include onion rings, mushroom cheese burger, fettuccine alfredo, hunter chicken breast, Cajun spiced hanger steak, old castle burger, California veggie burger and pepperoni pizza.

More

Vittoria Seafood & Grill
Vittoria Seafood & Grill
Reviews coming soon
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Vittoria Seafood & Grill is an upscale restaurant in Sheepshead Bay, New York. The interior dining room is attractive, with elegantly set tables and a trendy bar area. This is a great restaurant for a special date night or a celebratory dinner out. Guests can either choose to enjoy a classy Italian-American meal at the tables or indulge in a bottle of fine wine or a beer on tap at the bar.

Cuisine at Vittoria Seafood & Grill is mostly Italian dishes with some American inspiration as well. A variety of pasta with freshly made sauce, tasty seafood like lobster and oysters, thin-sliced beef and vegetarian dishes are all offered at Vittoria Seafood & Grill. For guests with special events coming up, all food from the menu can be ordered for catering services at events.

More

Maria Ristorante Italiano
Maria Ristorante Italiano
Reviews coming soon
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Maria Ristorante Italiano has been serving authentic Italian dishes for over 70 years. The restaurant is popular for its wide selection of traditionally cooked seafood specialties. It uses only fresh and high quality ingredients to create each dish. The charming and intimate ambiance at Maria Ristorante Italiano makes it a great place for a romantic dinner or special occasion. The restaurant also offers an extensive wine menu for guests to choose from.

Begin the meal at Maria Ristorante Italiano with a classic starter like zuppa di clams, salami provolone, baked clams, eggplant rollantine or stuffed mushrooms. Try the house special salad featuring seasonal greens, tomatoes, artichokes, cauliflower, olives, pimentos, genoa salami and provolone. Popular entr�e options include dishes like scallops Fra divalo, penne ala vodka, broiled Black Angus rib eye and veal pizzaiola.

More

Panini Tozt Cafe
Panini Tozt Cafe
Reviews coming soon
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Roll-n-roaster
Roll-n-roaster
Reviews coming soon
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Paradise Garden Restaurant
Paradise Garden Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
European | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Paradise Garden Restaurant serves traditional Russian cuisine and has a wide array of cold and hot beverages. It is a hip place, with a huge dance floor and both indoor and outdoor seating arrangement with a fantastic waterfront view. The ambiance at Paradise Garden Restaurant is fun and energetic and has a modern interior. The service staff is professional, courteous and friendly providing customers with an overall favorable experience.

It serves authentic Russian delicacies and is a good option to try when customers want to try out something new. Paradise garden restaurant has an extensive menu filled with Russian cuisine and a few French dishes.

More

Kouros Bay Diner
Kouros Bay Diner
Reviews coming soon
Cafe Dining | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

A casual and authentic Brooklyn diner offering breakfast, lunch and dinner in a relaxing caf� setting, Kouros Bay Diner uses quality ingredients to provide the most comforting and satisfying of flavors. At Kouros Bay Diner, enjoy popular breakfast items such as mozzarella omelets, Greek omelets, hot cereal, chili con carne, eggs Benedict, ham steak and a breakfast gyro.

For lunch and dinner selections at Kouros Bay Diner, try the matzo ball soup, classic cheeseburger, Greek fries, smoked salmon, grilled cheese and more. The diner hosts an extensive menu of items and varieties to guarantee satisfaction to every guest no matter the craving.

More

Cactus Restaurant
Cactus Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
Mexican | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Chopstix-Bk
Chopstix-Bk
Reviews coming soon
Chinese | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Chopstix BK in Brooklyn, New York specializes in serving authentic Chinese cuisine and sushi. The restaurant serves popular Chinese dishes with a modern twist as well as Japanese and American Chinese cuisine.

Chopstix BK serves lunch and dinner seven days a week and the menu features a mix of dumplings, noodles, chow mein, chop suey, fried rice, lo mein, egg fu young, vegetables, beef, roast pork, seafood, sushi and sashimi. Specialties served at Chopstix BK include sizzling tender steak, sizzling jumbo shrimp with vegetables, seafood chow fun, roast duck, Peking duck, sesame shrimp, mango chicken and Thai red curry sauce with chicken or beef.

More

Great Wall Kitchen
Great Wall Kitchen
Reviews coming soon
Chinese | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Henny Penny Chicken & Gyro
Henny Penny Chicken & Gyro
Reviews coming soon
Grill | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Thai Basil
Thai Basil
Reviews coming soon
Thai | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Dessert Palace
Dessert Palace
Reviews coming soon
Dessert | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Draft Barn
Draft Barn
Reviews coming soon
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Applebee's - Brooklyn
Applebee's - Brooklyn
Reviews coming soon
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Grab a hearty bite at Applebee's. This neighborhood restaurant specializes in traditional American comfort food, served in a relaxed space with a full-service bar. The dining menu offers an impressive range of choices, including pasta, seafood dishes, burgers, sandwiches and grilled fare. Diners rave about the baby back ribs, grilled shrimp skewers and grilled chicken breast. Applebee's also offers an appealing prix fixe double-entrée-plus-appetizer deal as well a special "lighter fare" menu, which features dishes with a lower calorie count.

Open all through the week, Applebee's provides a nice spot for socializing. Multiple TVs located around the dining area provide a steady stream of news updates and sports highlights. Guests can also choose from a tidy selection of beverages. You'll find frozen lemonade, soft drinks and flavored ice teas alongside alcohol-infused margaritas, sangrias, wine, beers and handcrafted cocktails.

More

Cats on the Bay
Cats on the Bay
(2)
French | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Took my friend out for lunch since we had a great experience last year at Duet Bakery Cafe. The food is really amazing, really great quality and very sophisticated. Even on a lunch menu there were a lot of things to choose from. To top: we were the only ones in the whole place, so that was kind of special. Would definitely recommend the place food wise! We weren't too impressed with the service, which was kind of tentative, maybe the lunch visitors are not that common there. Another thing we noticed is that the "Service Charge" of 18% was added to our bill automatically. More

OpenTable Diner -
XO Creperie
XO Creperie
Reviews coming soon
French | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

XO Creperie and Lounge is a unique restaurant and event space. It's gorgeous dining area is accented with large red velvet drapes all across the walls, glass chandeliers and eclectic decorations and lots of elaborate mirrors. XO Creperie does much more than serve food, it also has live music, entertainment and a waterfront patio where guests have a drink and take in the beautiful view.

XO Creperie's specialty is obviously crepes of all styles. The menu features both sweet and savory options. Some of the signature items include the salmon and bacon crepe, eggs benedict crepe and duck confit in cream of mushroom crepe. That's not the only type of options XO Creperie serves though, some of its other most popular items are dishes like the duck Wellington, grilled branzino and an Australian rack of lamb

More

Randazzo's Clam Bar
Randazzo's Clam Bar
Reviews coming soon
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Randazzo’s Clam Bar in Brooklyn boasts an old-school vibe that is casual and comfortable. Serving up Italian seafood along a waterfront setting, Randazzo’s Clam Bar has become a longtime favorite among the locals. There is also plenty of red sauce and raw bar fare available. Casual attire is encouraged, which makes for a perfect environment that appeals to hungry families.

Shrimp scampi on a bed of pasta, pasta with lobster sauce, stuffed filet, grilled chicken over salad and fried soft shell crabs are just some of the options diners can enjoy. Along with a variety of sodas and bottled or sparkling water, guests who dine at Randazzo’s Clam Bar can also enjoy a selection of beer, wine and cocktails.

More

Yiasou Estiatorio
Yiasou Estiatorio
(25)
Greek | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Yiasou is our favorite neighborhood restaurant. We probably visit two or even three times a month. Service is always delightful. They know we are small eaters but treat us with warm hospitality. The atmosphere is lovely and authentic. Food is exceptional and quantity more than enough. We love to share the Pikilia which offers a delightful array of Greek spreads. The Grilled Swordfish has always been a treat, deliciously prepared with capers and olive oil and served with potatoes and veggies or rice. The Shrimp Scampi in garlic and wine sauce is another favorite, sometimes better than others, while the swordfish is consistently amazing. They have the best Baklava ever and when you're really lucky they have delightful sugar cookies, usually gratis. Their coffee is delicious and the Greek red wine is as well. More

OpenTable Diner -
Momoyama
Momoyama
Reviews coming soon
Japanese | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Momoyama is a Japanese hibachi steakhouse and bar. The inside of the dining area is decorated to be extremely sharp and modern. The most striking feature inside Momoyama is the large hibachi grill at the back, which is constantly lighting up with flames while the chef behind it expertly cooks an array of ingredients for the guests.

Momoyama's menu has a good bit of variety. The menu is split mainly into two parts: hibachi entrŽes and sushi options. The hibachi works by having the guest select a protein that then gets cooked alongside rice and veggies. Some of these proteins include chicken, salmon, white tuna, rib eye steak, shrimp, scallops, Chilean sea bass, New York strip loin, lobster tail and mushrooms for vegetarians.

More

Cafe Tabu
Cafe Tabu
Reviews coming soon
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

KarVér
KarVér
(33)
Contemporary French / American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

For the best onion soup anywhere come right here. The restaurant is beautifully designed and the food just keeps getting better. The duck with sour cherries was amazing as was the strawberry tart. The service is outstanding. Seating is exceptionally comfortable. My Mom can’t eat whole entrees so I usually share with her. I asked then to divide the duck breast in the kitchen which they did beautifully. The restaurant operates and serves like a traditional French bistro. That means they are open for breakfast lunch and dinner. They also have a wonderful bakery if you just want coffee and a delectable pastry or gelato. More

OpenTable Diner -
Apple Grill
Apple Grill
Reviews coming soon
Grill | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Coming Soon!More

Sheepshead Bay Diners' Choice Winners

Sheepshead Bay's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Nargis Cafe
Nargis Cafe
(26)
Middle Eastern | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was excellent the decor pleasing and the service good BUT: the main courses should have been served all together instead of one of us eating while the others just watched. This was disturbing. More

OpenTable Diner -
Anthony's Place
Anthony's Place
(114)
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

See all offers

First time trying Anthony’s. Went on a Friday and they had great happy hour specials. Discounted drinks and appetizers. We had the red sangria which was excellent. We ordered the buffalo calamari, shrimp Oreganata and mussels. Also ordered baked clams from regular menu. Everything was great but the winner was the shrimp! Kelley, our waitress, was great. She was attentive and gave us great recommendations. We were full but ordered the veal chop for dinner and the chopped salad (Bobb salad) to share and the other person had the lasagne. The salad was light and delicious! I tasted the lasagne which I thought was great. The veal chop was a little on the tough side but had great flavor. The chef stopped by the table to see how everything was and gave us a taste of the homemade wine he makes on the house. So good!! Dessert was his homemade Italian cheesecake which was delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Next Door
Next Door
(42)
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was incredible! The staff were welcoming and friendly. Overall, great dining experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
Blu Turkish Restaurant
Blu Turkish Restaurant
(50)
Turkish | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Excellent food and service. Highly recommend! More

OpenTable Diner -
Il Fornetto
Il Fornetto
(207)
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

I wanted a very scenic place with great food and excellent service as my long time friend was coming in to visit from Connecticut. She also wanted a fresh seafood option. Il Fornetto totally fits the bill! We had the fish of the day and a salad. Shared both and portion size was adequate. The fish came garnished with two large wedges of roasted potatoes which were excellent. The arugula salad was fresh and full of pistachios, goat cheese and perfectly dressed. I would definitely come back with company again! More

OpenTable Diner -
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
(16)
Sushi | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Outstanding!! More

OpenTable Diner -
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
(86)
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Nice and clean and very tasty More

OpenTable Diner -