Best American Restaurants in New Milford

Amazing brunch spot. Our Waitress was WONDERFUL! Food delicious! Tasty creative drinks. Definitely worth a visit!

Exceptional restaurant in a unique area of new milford. You can catch a movie before or after eating at the theater across the street. Great menu choices for all ages. Specials menu is perfect

The experience last evening was absolutely superb. The service, the ambiance, the presentation - all spectacular. Arethusa is on it's game and has set the standard. Photograph-worthy presentation with the taste to match. Every aspect was memorable and we are still talking about it! Our regards to the Arethusa al Tavolo Host, Peter.

Lily our server made us feel so welcome!! She sat us at our favorite table and made me my favorite drink that wasn’t on the menu anymore!! My family and I love all the delicious food and we always have the most wonderful time at this beautiful restaurant!! We will be back again and again!! The lamb chops were cooked to perfection and the short ribs are amazing!!! We dip the bread into the gravy and never leave a morsel!! The chef is wonderful and all the staff are friendly and so attentive!! Thank you!!

I love Florrie Kaye's Tea Room. I and anyone I'm dining with have never been disappointed. Whatever dish I order is amazing. The ambiance is wonderful. I thoroughly recommend Florrie Kaye's Tea Room.