Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Amazing!!! We ordered the fish, pork chop and lasagna for the table + appetizers - Brussel sprouts, meatballs and grilled shrimp on toasted bread. Cocktails didn’t disappoint. Best gin martini. Spectacular view and service. Thank you for a beautiful night!

We had a wonderful dining experience at Cesarina. We were seated promptly (arriving right on our reservation time). The service was efficient and our server was very familiar with the menu, and frank and open with his descriptions/comments about various menu items. The food was served surprisingly promptly, and everything our party of 3 had was delicious. The pasta was exceptional. Everyone we interacted with acknowledged my wife's birthday (which was the occasion we were celebrating). The atmosphere is comfortable and not too noisy (of overly loud). We had a wonderful evening and everyone at Cesarina should be commended for the fine job/product they provide.

This place never disappoints! Rosanna was the nicest server and took care of us perfectly. The service and the food was wonderful like always. We couldn’t have picked a better place to spend our anniversary.

It was great all the way around just one thing it’s supposed to be a sports bar. We’re there to watch sports and have good food but then they put a two hour limit on the tables which is unusual. Large groups of people are there to watch a specific game, they made the reservations to watch the game at a place where there’s good food and atmosphere. You simply cannot kick them out after two hours ?

This place is a real gem! Our third time here and we loved it as much as the first two - something that doesn't often occur at least in our experiences! The service is fabulous - every single one of the staff are very friendly and kind. They are all smiling and welcoming! I had a really good Lemoncelli cocktail that was light and refreshing and the rest of my party enjoyed a glass of red wine. Their food is delicious - I selected the fettuccini alfredo with chicken and it was amazing. The pasta was cooked perfectly and the sauce was really good. My husband and both of our friends chose the pappardelle pasta with Italian sausage and Bolognese sauce and they all loved it. We will definitely take more friends to this place! It's truly a great Italian gem in Little Italy!