24 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Toms River

24 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Oolala Lasagna

new

3.6

Very Good(16)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Brick

Booked 1 time today

The food and service were excellent. It is a family owned business that really caters to their customers.

2. AP Rooftop

4.6

Exceptional(972)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Asbury Park

Booked 24 times today

We’ve been here before, and the place never disappoints. (Ok, at the height of tourist season, it can get a little crazy, but what can you do?) The food is usually top-notch, nice wine list (comparable to other such places), and the service is always spot on- from the front desk to the wait staff to the food runners! Shout out to Katelyn, who we’ve had the pleasure of being at her tables a couple of times! Oh, and the ambiance is spectacular

3. Piccola Italia

4.9

Exceptional(745)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Asbury Park

Booked 2 times today

Food is fantastic. Service is great. Always a good evening.

4. Villaggio Iccara

4.8

Exceptional(2757)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Yardville

Booked 17 times today

We had a perfect experience. 10/10! Flawless service, and the food was perfectly cooked and seasoned.

5. La Cipollina

4.8

Exceptional(1049)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Freehold

Booked 2 times today

Excellent service in a perfect atmosphere. Ben was our server and he was a true professional from start to finish. We had the 100 layer lasagna and the pork chop and both were prepared perfectly. If you're adventurous, try the Sardinian cucumber desert. I mean c'mon, when are you going to see cucumbers on a desert menu.

A photo of Nonna's Citi Cucina restaurant

6. Nonna's Citi Cucina

4.8

Exceptional(1473)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Englishtown

Booked 15 times today

First time at Nonna’s. The Service and Food are outstanding. The price point is also very competitive. Very friendly staff and accommodating as our table had tree nut and peanut allergies. There are two sides of the restaurant. We were on the right side, which was a bit noisy. Perfectly fine as it’s a lively environment, but if you’re looking for something a bit more on the quiet side, we noticed the left side of the line was a bit more quieter. Nice touches the had complementary valet parking.

A photo of Piccolo Trattoria - Newtown restaurant

7. Piccolo Trattoria - Newtown

4.6

Exceptional(1496)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Newtown

Booked 46 times today

Our servers Jodi and Dan were fantastic. Our cocktails and food were outstanding. The owner is always there checking on everything. We always have a wonderful dining experience!

8. Ponte Vecchio

4.6

Exceptional(904)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Old Bridge

Booked 6 times today

Once again a wonderful dinner, never disappoints, the specials were excellent the Halibut was delicious.

9. Johnny Piancone's

4.7

Exceptional(79)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Long Branch

Booked 1 time today

Unbelievable food tonight. The host was so accomodating and apologized for the wait of 20 minutes and offered us a drink on him. Amy our waitress is one of the best in the restaurant. Just amazing all around! The Greco's

A photo of Limoncello at Piazza di Roma restaurant

10. Limoncello at Piazza di Roma

4.8

Exceptional(125)

€€€€

• Sicilian • Matawan

Booked 1 time today

We love Limoncellos! It’s such a beautiful, pristine restaurant! The owners are lovely people. The service was great and the food was delicious. We are return customers and will continue to come forever! ❤️

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Toms River

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

24 restaurants available nearby

1. Oolala Lasagna

2. AP Rooftop

3. Piccola Italia

4. Villaggio Iccara

5. La Cipollina

6. Nonna's Citi Cucina

7. Piccolo Trattoria - Newtown

8. Ponte Vecchio

9. Johnny Piancone's

10. Limoncello at Piazza di Roma

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable