Best Southern American Restaurants in Mackinac Island

Price

€€
€€€
€€€€

Regions

Northern Michigan

Southern Ontario

Areas

Bay Harbor

Boyne City

Boyne Falls

Brutus

Charlevoix

Harbor Springs

Top Rated

Charming

Dog-friendly

Fancy

Good for business meals

Good for groups

Good for special occasions

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeaway only

Seating options

Bar

Counter

Standard

High Top

Outdoor

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

29 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Carriage House at Hotel Iroquois restaurant

1. Carriage House at Hotel Iroquois

4.8

Exceptional(1766)

€€€€

• Southern american • Mackinac Island

Booked 72 times today

Carriage House at Hotel Iroquois on Mackinac Island is a beacon of exceptional Seafood cuisine, celebrated for its "perfectly cooked" dishes that showcase the finest local catches. Under the masterful direction of Chef Greg Murphy, the restaurant's signature Carriage House whitefish from Lake Superior is a standout, consistently praised for its "delicious" taste and "beautiful presentation." Guests rave about the setting as much as the food, with its breathtaking views of the Straits of Mackinac enhancing the dining experience. The combination of "outstanding" service and exquisite Seafood makes Carriage House a must-visit for any seafood connoisseur.

2. 1852 Grill Room

4.7

Exceptional(1399)

€€€€

• Southern american • Mackinac Island

Booked 40 times today

When it comes to Mackinac Island dining, 1852 Grill Room is a standout, offering a refined dining experience in a casually sophisticated atmosphere. A live pianist sets the ambiance of an enchanting evening highlighted by brilliant harbor views from the elegant dining room or waterfront terrace patio. Discover exceptional culinary craftsmanship starring chophouse favorites, locally sourced fresh fish, and gourmet desserts. Add a reservation at 1852 Grill Room for a positively memorable evening out.

3. Ice House BBQ

4.7

Exceptional(178)

€€€€

• Southern american • Mackinac Island

Booked 31 times today

Escape the hustle of downtown to a secluded hideaway, just enough off the beaten path to enjoy Mackinac Island’s natural beauty, without interrupting awaiting adventures. Menu selections are mouthwatering creative twists to your favorite backyard classics. Follow the path to the left of the Island House Hotel across from the marina to discover this hidden gem, open Memorial Day through Labor Day, weather permitting.

A photo of Great Turtle Brewery & Distillery restaurant

4. Great Turtle Brewery & Distillery

(0)

€€€€

• Southern american • Mackinac Island

Voted the #1 brewery north of the Mackinac Bridge in 2022. It all began in the summer of 2019 with the creation of Mackinac Island's only brewery and distillery. From our exclusive craft beers and hand crafted cocktails to the playful menu and daily live music, The Great Turtle offers something for everyone. Some of our greatest hits include our Big Aft Double IPA, Mackinac Summer Sour, Painted Turtle Cocktail Flights, Nashville Hot Chicken Mac and Cheese and our giant Shell Yeah burger. We also offer a full kids menu and a dog friendly patio for the fur babies. Don't miss our retail shop where we offer plenty of GTBD swag as well as our signature craft beers in cans to take home. We are conveniently located across from the Shepler's Ferry dock on the corner of Main and Hoban Street.

A photo of Round Island Kitchen restaurant

5. Round Island Kitchen

4.4

Awesome(327)

€€€€

• Southern american • Mackinac Island

Booked 33 times today

Round Island Kitchen, nestled in the charming locale of Mackinac Island, is a beacon of genuine Farm-to-table cuisine. Known for its creative and well-prepared dishes, the restaurant delights with "high-quality ingredients" that bring local flavors to the forefront. Diners rave about the "generous portions" and the wide variety of delectable options, showcasing the kitchen's dedication to fresh, locally-sourced produce. The "phenomenal view" and "exceptional service" further elevate the dining experience, making it a memorable highlight of any visit to this iconic island. Whether savoring a hearty brunch or a delightful dinner, Round Island Kitchen promises an authentic taste of Michigan.

6. The Straits

4.4

Awesome(41)

€€€€

• Southern american • Mackinac Island

Booked 18 times today

The Straits is the premier fine-dining experience at The Inn at Stonecliffe. Located inside the historic mansion's main dining room, our signature restaurant draws inspiration from the Great Lakes and features locally sourced ingredients. Delectable dishes, bold cocktails, and savory desserts come together in a setting that reflects timeless Midwestern charm. Dining at The Straits means becoming part of a storied tradition in an unforgettable setting.

A photo of The White Buffalo Bar & Grille restaurant

7. The White Buffalo Bar & Grille

4.6

Exceptional(45)

€€€€

• Southern american • Mackinaw City

Booked 19 times today

DOORS OPEN APRIL 30TH FOR OUR 2026 SEASON. BOOK YOUR RESERVATION NOW! At The White Buffalo Bar & Grille we serve local, fresh, and healthy food. Located in historic downtown Mackinaw City, just steps from the ferry docks, our menu features bison raised at a local farm and fish caught daily. Enjoy the health benefits of lean bison meat and omega-3 rich fish while supporting local businesses. Join us for a nourishing dining experience that celebrates our community and your well-being. We offer finer dining as well as a more casual rooftop experience.

8. Pier Restaurant

4.1

Excellent(362)

€€€€

• Southern american • Harbor Springs

Booked 64 times today

Nestled in the picturesque setting of Harbor Springs, the Pier Restaurant offers a standout experience in Contemporary American cuisine. With a menu that masterfully combines fresh Great Lakes fish and hand-cut beef with locally sourced ingredients, diners are treated to a delightful culinary journey. Reviewers rave about the "excellent food and outstanding service," with a special nod to the "exceptional fish entrees" and "perfectly cooked filets." The restaurant's ambiance, enhanced by stunning waterfront views, creates the perfect backdrop for enjoying a meal. Whether dining outdoors or indoors, the Pier Restaurant is a must-visit destination for those seeking authentic Contemporary American flavors.

9. NOMAD.

4.7

Exceptional(634)

€€€€

• Southern american • Petoskey

Booked 52 times today

About NOMAD.Located on the waterfront in Bay Harbor, NOMAD. offers a vibrant atmosphere that pairs well with its sharable plates, evolving wine list, and house cocktails.Our menu was artfully crafted through the senses of a NOMAD, with flavors and influences from across the world by our Executive Chef, Chef Jeffrey Summers.Opened in Spring 2022, our mission is to continuously evolve while always maintaining exceptional quality and creativity. Please note if booking outside dining, restaurant can't hold inside tables if inclement weather occurs. Thank you for your understanding.

A photo of Trovato at Hidden River restaurant

10. Trovato at Hidden River

4.7

Exceptional(405)

€€€€

• Southern american • Brutus

Booked 22 times today

Trovato at Hidden River in Brutus, Michigan, offers an exceptional American dining experience that beautifully melds contemporary flair with classic flavors. Guests rave about the "spectacular food" and "excellent service," highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity in American cuisine. Diners are treated to a varied menu that showcases the best in local ingredients, with standout dishes like the scallops and short rib risotto receiving high praise. The picturesque setting along the Maple River adds to the restaurant's charm, creating a dining atmosphere that is both "tranquil" and "cosmopolitan," making it a must-visit for anyone seeking quality American cuisine.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Area
Southern american cuisine

Mackinac Island

Boyne Falls
Petoskey / Boyne City
Bellaire
Maple City
Glen Arbor / Maple City
Indian River
Munising
Suttons Bay
Cadillac
Mancelona
Hessel
Acme
Boyne City
Kalkaska
Manistee
Elk Rapids
Harbor Springs
Petoskey
Bingham
Ludington