509 Best Authentic Restaurants in West Sayville

A photo of Sunflower Café & Bakery restaurant

1. Sunflower Café & Bakery

4.8

Exceptional(250)

€€€€

• French • Bayport

Booked 6 times today

Amazing French food with great service at real prices. That’s the trifecta

2. Osteria Umbra

4.8

Exceptional(2316)

€€€€

• Italian • Smithtown

Booked 15 times today

Nice fresh oysters and fantastic steaks, appetizer of the cheese wheel fantastic. Pistachio cake for dessert one of the best

3. Bar Clementine

4.9

Exceptional(214)

€€€€

• Bistro • Islip

Booked 10 times today

Had a lovely evening with my friend. We enjoyed the dinner prefixe and shared our entrees. Added dessert and left pleasantly full! The food was delicious and our waitress was lovely. Will definitely be going back!

4. Pecado Mexican

4.4

Awesome(599)

€€€€

• Contemporary Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 10 times today

Food was fabulous. A variety of tacos and a great salad. Shared a pumpkin cheesecake which was excellent! Our server, Alex was terrific.

A photo of Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue restaurant

5. Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue

4.6

Exceptional(451)

€€€€

• Mexican • Patchogue

Booked 8 times today

Food was delicious. The service was really good, from the server to I think manager or owner who was going around making sure everyone was doing well and even gave us free shots. They had a mariachi band which was great, and even took requests. Had such a good girls night there. Drinks were on point too. Pleasently surprised with this place !

6. Salt and Barrel

4.7

Exceptional(1877)

€€€€

• Contemporary American • Bay Shore

Booked 7 times today

This was our second time eating at Salt and Barrel, and we thoroughly enjoyed our dinner. We shared tuna tartare for starters, and then my husband ordered oysters for his main course. He was pleased with the variety he had to choose from and the presentation was perfect. I had the Bucatini for my main course served with the tiniest of clams. Our waiter was excellent. We will definitely be going to this restaurant again.

A photo of Blackstone Steakhouse restaurant

7. Blackstone Steakhouse

4.7

Exceptional(6751)

€€€€

• Steakhouse • Melville

Booked 64 times today

I brought a friend to Blackstone for his birthday. He had never been there before. He was BLOWN AWAY! First, the service is just impeccable. From the beautiful, friendly greeter to the busboys, everyone is friendly and they seem genuinely happy to help in any way. The restaurant itself is just stunning. It is a huge place, but you still feel intimate enough to enjoy your conversation and not feel crowded at all at the tables. Dress is casual dressy. Most of the guests looked classy and well put together. My friend couldn't believe how many people were there on a quiet Thursday night We saw the infamous Sal who came over to greet us. He is the picture of class and so sweet. He knows everything about everything. Our waitress, Jessica, was so friendly and helpful. She was so happy and answered all of our questions with a big smile. Best service in a really long time. Then, came the food. I know that whatever I write here will not do it justice, but I will do my best. We started with the fresh Semolina bread and dipped it in the delicious oil. Then, came the main course! A perfectly seared, medium rare Porterhouse for two. It isn't cheap, but it is worth every single cent! They bring it to the table and slice it up. The first bite is so incredibly tasty and the knife cuts through it like butter. I closed my eyes and relished that delicious fresh, satisfying bite of perfectly aged Porterhouse. Wow! We got the mushroom risotto and a baked potato on the side. They did not disappoint. The mushroom risotto was so creamy and tasty. It was really delicious and perfectly cooked. For dessert, they brought a fresh apple cider donut with this delicious cream on it. Yummy! We also ordered a creme brulée. It was perfection, with a crispy, savory crust and just the right amount of sweetness in the cream. It was the perfect ending to a perfect meal! Don't cheat yourself! Go to Blackstone and experience perfection in every way. Thank you for a wonderfully delicious evening!

8. Mamma Lombardi's

4.8

Exceptional(774)

€€€€

• Italian • Holbrook

Booked 8 times today

Last night I was thrilled to see that fresh fluke was on the special menu. Fabulous! The fish was presented to me whole before cooking… then afterward served deboned with a sautéed olive oil, garlic, tomato, capers and black olives! Delicious!

A photo of Primi Italian Steakhouse restaurant

9. Primi Italian Steakhouse

4.8

Exceptional(1728)

€€€€

• Italian • West Islip

Booked 26 times today

This is the third time we have been here and every single time. It is amazing! Services on point! Food is excellent… Absolutely love the decor… We will absolutely be back!

A photo of Pietro Cucina Italiana restaurant

10. Pietro Cucina Italiana

4.5

Awesome(709)

€€€€

• Italian • St. James

Booked 7 times today

2 Been here twice now. Food was excellent both times. First time, we had a seafood special which was great. Service was excellent. Last night I had a homemade rigatoni with eggplant which was delicious. My wife had the rage with GF spaghetti which she loved. The burrata appetizer was also delicious. It's a quaint place inside, very clean. The owner was very nice and accommodating and our water was excellent.

Best Authentic Restaurants in West Sayville

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Award-winning

Accessibility

509 restaurants available nearby

1. Sunflower Café & Bakery

2. Osteria Umbra

3. Bar Clementine

4. Pecado Mexican

5. Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue

6. Salt and Barrel

7. Blackstone Steakhouse

8. Mamma Lombardi's

9. Primi Italian Steakhouse

10. Pietro Cucina Italiana

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable