44 Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Islip

44 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Blackstone Steakhouse restaurant

1. Blackstone Steakhouse

4.7

Exceptional(6757)

€€€€

• Steakhouse • Melville

Booked 74 times today

Best dining experience we have had in a long time. Everything was fresh, delicious, and a great value. The staff was excellent!

2. Prospect On Union

4.4

Awesome(35)

€€€€

• American • West Islip

Booked 5 times today

We tried drinks, apps, entrees and desserts. Everything was amazing! Not a single complaint from anyone. Def will be returning!

A photo of Vincent's Clam Bar restaurant

3. Vincent's Clam Bar

4.8

Exceptional(3264)

€€€€

• Italian • Carle Place

Booked 42 times today

It Never disappoints for the value! Service was awesome ..and food was pretty good ! Never feels rushed..and it can serve as a great escape ..(esp during lunch hour! Buon Appetito!!

4. Mamma Lombardi's

4.8

Exceptional(777)

€€€€

• Italian • Holbrook

Booked 6 times today

Dinner last night at Mama Lombardi’s was absolutely perfect. The ambience was warm, cozy and relaxing. The food was delicious! But what truly made our dinner last night unforgettable was our server Antonio. He was AMAZING!!! He went completely above and beyond for us to ensure everything was perfect. Every single recommendation he made was spot-on. His incredible service combined with the quaint, relaxing ambiance and scrumptious food made for a flawless dining experience. We will definitely be back!

5. Bar Frites

4.7

Exceptional(1932)

€€€€

• French • Greenvale

Booked 40 times today

Consistently good food and service. Their tuna tartare and white pizza are some of the best we’ve had, and they’re staff is very friendly.

A photo of The Villager Farmingdale restaurant

6. The Villager Farmingdale

4.4

Awesome(91)

€€€€

• American • Farmingdale

Booked 4 times today

The waiter was really nice and attentive. I got a burger and fries and it was amazing. Drinks were good, it was energetic inside but not crazy loud, and the price wasnt too bad. I’ll definitely be back!

A photo of Sayville Falls Mini Golf and Beer Garden restaurant

7. Sayville Falls Mini Golf and Beer Garden

4.6

Exceptional(13)

€€€€

• Burgers • Sayville

It was a great place to come hang out after a tournament day!

A photo of Çka Ka Qellu - Stamford restaurant

8. Çka Ka Qellu - Stamford

4.5

Awesome(338)

€€€€

• Mediterranean • Stamford

Booked 17 times today

The dishes were outstanding, and the service was equally exceptional. Our waiter was attentive throughout the evening, and we especially appreciated that our special occasion was thoughtfully acknowledged. The restaurant's ambiance is unique, elegant, and tastefully decorated, creating a wonderful setting for the meal. The only downside was the noise level, which was much louder than expected and detracted from the overall experience. For that reason, I'm deducting one star.

A photo of Avianna's Carriage House restaurant

9. Avianna's Carriage House

3.9

Excellent(8)

€€€€

• American • Melville

Booked 6 times today

Olivia was our server , she was lovely , her service was top notch ! Our food was excellent! Great experience all around

10. Hendrick's Tavern

4.7

Exceptional(2931)

€€€€

• American • Roslyn

Booked 68 times today

Staff immediately had us sit by a cozy fire awaiting for the rest of our crew to arrive. Once we were all there the waiter right away sat us down. Food was amazing and the waiter made sure if we needed anything. This place is a 10 out of 10!

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Islip

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

44 restaurants available nearby

1. Blackstone Steakhouse

2. Prospect On Union

3. Vincent's Clam Bar

4. Mamma Lombardi's

5. Bar Frites

6. The Villager Farmingdale

7. Sayville Falls Mini Golf and Beer Garden

8. Çka Ka Qellu - Stamford

9. Avianna's Carriage House

10. Hendrick's Tavern

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable