13 Best Restaurants for Local Ingredients in Edgartown

13 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Restaurant Foster and Mermaid Bar at Lambert's Cove Inn restaurant

1. Restaurant Foster and Mermaid Bar at Lambert's Cove Inn

4.9

Exceptional(695)

€€€€

• Contemporary American • Martha's Vineyard

Booked 5 times today

We had a great time! Professional service but welcoming and friendly. Really cozy beautiful dining room. Really good, local, interesting food!

A photo of The Rooftop at Pelham House Resort restaurant

2. The Rooftop at Pelham House Resort

4.6

Exceptional(3227)

€€€€

• Contemporary American • Dennis Port

Booked 8 times today

I can't recommend The Rooftop more highly. First, the view is spectacular. Then, the food and service were top notch. From fresh oysters to an eclectic menu featuring a shrimp cornbread and spicy lobster ravioli, go make a reservation now.

3. Ships Inn

4.9

Exceptional(610)

€€€€

• American • Nantucket

Exceptional all around! From the moment you walk through the door, you are greeted by a warm and welcoming team, and the service is outstanding. The menu offers so many tempting selections that it’s difficult to choose! I started with the Shrimp Gumbo, featuring andouille sausage and fried okra, followed by the Sautéed Halibut, served with wild mushroom risotto, pea purée, and morel sauce. Every bite was beyond delicious! A truly wonderful dining experience from start to finish. I look forward to returning!

4. The Lantern Room

4.0

Excellent(156)

€€€€

• American • Falmouth

Booked 7 times today

The experience was much better than we anticipated given the just a little above average rating that we had seen for it. Both the food and service were excellent.

5. BOCCA

4.7

Exceptional(2541)

€€€€

• Italian • Fairhaven

Booked 31 times today

Excellent experience Food was great as we both tried some new items which were outstanding Baked Stuffed Shrimp and the Apple Glazed Salmon

A photo of Millan’s Restaurant restaurant

6. Millan’s Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(292)

€€€€

• Global, International • Truro

Excellent food and service. The lemon ricotta cake was outstanding, as were the sauces, beet salad, pear salad, and garlic knots.

7. Remy's Loose

4.8

Exceptional(1112)

€€€€

• Contemporary French / American • Newport

Booked 8 times today

The restaurant is absolutely stunning and the service was top notch. Lunch before the Cliff Walk was a perfect choice.

8. Surf Club

4.4

Awesome(506)

€€€€

• American • Newport

Booked 9 times today

Always cozy and warm. For a group of 6+ you can’t beat a booth at the Surf club. Side note , thefall sangria is delicious!

9. Vieste

4.7

Exceptional(193)

€€€€

• Italian • Newport

Booked 15 times today

Great Italian style restaurant just a few blocks from the Wharf area in Newport.

A photo of Aurelia at Castle Hill restaurant

10. Aurelia at Castle Hill

4.9

Exceptional(2772)

€€€€

• Farm-to-table • Newport

Booked 5 times today

Without question, dining at Aurelia is a one of the finest experiences my family and I have ever experienced. In this case, we also ordered the Sommelier experience. It was well worth it and added a level of elegance to the meal. We highly recommend dining there. As per my wife, dining there is the standard all other first class restaurants should be judged against.

Best Restaurants for Local Ingredients in Edgartown

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Areas

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

13 restaurants available nearby

1. Restaurant Foster and Mermaid Bar at Lambert's Cove Inn

2. The Rooftop at Pelham House Resort

3. Ships Inn

4. The Lantern Room

5. BOCCA

6. Millan’s Restaurant

7. Remy's Loose

8. Surf Club

9. Vieste

10. Aurelia at Castle Hill

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable