Restaurants near Pena-Peck House

Loved the atmosphere and the service was excellent. Great meal: she crab soup, heirloom beet salad (best ever!) and filet cooked to perfection. The menu is somewhat limited, but what is offered is done well. Exceeded expectations for a hotel restaurant. Would definitely dine here again.

What a fantastic place to eat. The food quality and taste were top notch. Everyone was professional and really good. Even though I consider this a high end restaurant, the staff were real people who didn't talk or act like stiff programmed robots. We didn't wait long for any part of our meal yet we had plenty of time to eat each serving. The filet just peeled off with a fork. I tasted my wife's Blackened Grouper and it was the best fish dish I've ever tasted (even more than Chilean Sea Bass I have had over the years - that's not in the menu, though). Everything on the menu looked so very good. It was difficult to decide. I really believe the staff was very happy to be there. They were enjoying their work. We'll be going back there for future occasions.

Another excellent dining experience at Forgotten Tonic. This place never disappoints. It’s why we come back again and again and again. Excellent food, genuine service, and some of the best craft cocktails in Florida. Don’t miss out on this gem.

There was a natural gas smell very strong when we walked in. The hostess seemed perturbed that we asked about it assured us it was being g looked into and was safe. Waitress could not have been more attentive and pleasant. 1905 salad prepared table side was not as I have had it in the past. It was premade just adding lemon and Worcestershire sauce to it. It use to be all the ingredients were added in front of you. Overall it was good

Such a dreamy place in Old Town St. Augustine. Our meal was just amazing, service was great. Will be back next time we are in town.