Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Bay Shore

View all

Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

View all

Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Tavern on the Green
(2734)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
Sushi Yasaka
(966)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Satisfy your craving: Explore Bay Shore restaurants.

  • Restaurant List
  • Best restaurants

Bay Shore Restaurants

Satisfy your craving: Explore Bay Shore restaurants.

Bay Shore Restaurants

The LakehouseThe Lakehouse
1111 reviews
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Our favorite place to celebrate! More

OpenTable Diner -
Salt and BarrelSalt and Barrel
672 reviews
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

We had an amazing dinner. All of the oysters were perfect and the main dishes were delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Captain Bill'sCaptain Bill's
772 reviews
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The food was great and so was the service More

OpenTable Diner -
Verde Kitchen & CocktailsVerde Kitchen & Cocktails
431 reviews
Mexican | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Order a cocktail! As soon as we walked in, the service was great. Offered us our choice of tables and rooms. We chose the solarium and it was nice and cozy. Our waiter Corey was attentive and helpful. I ordered the Tropical cocktail and it was delish! We order the trio Guacamole as an appetizer and I could have eaten it out of the bowl sans the chips! I had the fish tacos for dinner and my friend had the Whole Porgy. Both were great choices, due to the amount of chips I ate, I only at the taco filling. Which was still just as tasty and satisfying. But... the side of rice was fluffy and delicious. It was my 2nd favorite after the cocktail. More

OpenTable Diner -
Bella VieBella Vie
113 reviews
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The Gnocchi was the best I've ever had. Our party of 7 vowed to return. I want to try the broccoli ravioli next. Not thrilled with the wine list. I would like to see Moscato offered. It was a bit pricey, but definetly worth it. It now rates with Mario's in Happauge with me for best Italian restaurant on LI. More

OpenTable Diner -
Corks and Taps of New York inc.Corks and Taps of New York inc.
31 reviews
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

We waited at the bar while our table was getting prepared. The bartenders did not have great service it took us a little while before they acknowledged us. Then when we were at our table the waiter never told us about the specials. The food was pretty good other than that. There was a live band that was good but a little too loud. If they were a little lower it would have been nicer. We couldn’t really hear the people we were with. All in all good experience we’d go back. More

OpenTable Diner -
WhalersWhalers
105 reviews
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Great service and food was always fresh and delicious as always. Service was beyond my expectations, there was always someone around Incase you needed something. More

OpenTable Diner -
TGI FRIDAYS - BayshoreTGI FRIDAYS - Bayshore
6 reviews
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Had such a great time. Went on a Sunday and took advantage of their new happy hour specials. Boneless wings of all flavors were delicious as we're the sliders. Our server Diamond was the best. More

OpenTable Diner -

Bay Shore Diners' Choice Winners

Bay Shore's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
The LakehouseThe Lakehouse
1111 reviews
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Our favorite place to celebrate! More

OpenTable Diner -
Captain Bill'sCaptain Bill's
772 reviews
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The food was great and so was the service More

OpenTable Diner -
Salt and BarrelSalt and Barrel
672 reviews
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

We had an amazing dinner. All of the oysters were perfect and the main dishes were delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Verde Kitchen & CocktailsVerde Kitchen & Cocktails
431 reviews
Mexican | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Order a cocktail! As soon as we walked in, the service was great. Offered us our choice of tables and rooms. We chose the solarium and it was nice and cozy. Our waiter Corey was attentive and helpful. I ordered the Tropical cocktail and it was delish! We order the trio Guacamole as an appetizer and I could have eaten it out of the bowl sans the chips! I had the fish tacos for dinner and my friend had the Whole Porgy. Both were great choices, due to the amount of chips I ate, I only at the taco filling. Which was still just as tasty and satisfying. But... the side of rice was fluffy and delicious. It was my 2nd favorite after the cocktail. More

OpenTable Diner -
Corks and Taps of New York inc.Corks and Taps of New York inc.
31 reviews
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

We waited at the bar while our table was getting prepared. The bartenders did not have great service it took us a little while before they acknowledged us. Then when we were at our table the waiter never told us about the specials. The food was pretty good other than that. There was a live band that was good but a little too loud. If they were a little lower it would have been nicer. We couldn’t really hear the people we were with. All in all good experience we’d go back. More

OpenTable Diner -
Bella VieBella Vie
113 reviews
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The Gnocchi was the best I've ever had. Our party of 7 vowed to return. I want to try the broccoli ravioli next. Not thrilled with the wine list. I would like to see Moscato offered. It was a bit pricey, but definetly worth it. It now rates with Mario's in Happauge with me for best Italian restaurant on LI. More

OpenTable Diner -
WhalersWhalers
105 reviews
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Great service and food was always fresh and delicious as always. Service was beyond my expectations, there was always someone around Incase you needed something. More

OpenTable Diner -