Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(782)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
Tavern on the Green
(2750)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
Café Boulud
(708)
$$$$
French | Upper East Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Fire Island restaurants

  • Restaurant List

Fire Island Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Fire Island restaurants

Fire Island Restaurants

Island Mermaid
Island Mermaid
Reviews coming soon
Cafe Dining | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Island Mermaid in Ocean Beach, NY offers a casual and yet elegant seaside dining experience. Lunchtime favorites at Island Mermaid include the Mermaid Cobb salad, BBQ chicken sandwich, Cuban media noche and fish tacos.

For dinner at Island Mermaid, try the pan-seared sea scallops, linguini frutta di mare or the sautŽed grouper filet. The brunch menu includes a smoked salmon bagel platter, huevos rancheros and blueberry ginger stuffed French toast. If youÕre in the mood for an adult beverage, try the basil berry, the Mermaid margarita or the jalapeno watermelon margarita. Island Mermaid is equipped to accommodate large and small parties and has a prix fixe menu for parties of 15 or more.

More

Surf's Out
Surf's Out
(87)
American | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

End of Summer celebration More

OpenTable Diner -
Flynn's Restaurant & Marina
Flynn's Restaurant & Marina
Reviews coming soon
Steakhouse | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Pines Bistro
Pines Bistro
Reviews coming soon
Pizzeria | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Pines Bistro is a sophisticated continental restaurant that offers a variety of traditional American favorites as well as daily-changing house specials. The restaurant is committed to sourcing all of its produce and meat from local producers and farms in an ethical and responsible manner. Pines Bistro provides a comfortable lounge-style environment and serves food through all seasons. When the weather is nice, outdoor seating is also available.

Popular appetizers to start the meal with include lightly battered fried calamari with spicy marinara, mussels and clams saut�ed in white wine and garlic, mushrooms stuffed with crab meat and marinated artichoke hearts grilled and served with shaved Parmigiana. For the main course at Pines Bistro, try the house special grilled Atlantic salmon drizzled with balsamic glaze and served over saut�ed spinach with a side of potatoes.

More

Cricket's
Cricket's
Reviews coming soon
American | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

CricketÕs offers burgers, steaks and seafood in a British pub-like atmosphere. The open floor plan leaves plenty of room to move around the tables, and the high stools around the bar are well spaced. Enjoy an appetizer of fried calamari, baked clams or broccoli and cheddar poppers with bits of bacon as you decide on an entrŽe. Choose from classics such as the liver and bacon or the chicken Cricket served with marsala sauce, plum tomatoes, mushrooms and onions topped with sherry and melted Swiss or opt for one of several seafood plates. CricketÕs also offers several types of sandwiches and sandwich platters that include the grilled Reuben, turkey club, chicken panini and open roast beef sandwich.

Beverages offered at CricketÕs include both red and white wines served by the glass or carafe, beer by the bottle or on draft as well as soft drinks, iced tea and lemonade.

More

Maguire's
Maguire's
Reviews coming soon
American | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Maguire's offers patio seating with beautiful sunset views on the water. It serves American food and seafood, and there is a bar as well. Maguire's has daily specials and live music.

Try appetizers such as the Long Island steamers, tuna tartare, steamed mussels scampi or the hot wings. Dinner options include vegan farro risotto, lobster, Alaskan king crab legs or grilled skirt steak. Pair it with sides such as the coconut jasmine rice, roasted brussel sprouts or garlic mashed potatoes. Maguire's serves lunch options that include burgers, wraps and the catch of the day. Bring your children, and they can choose from the kids' menu. Dessert options include Key lime pie, homemade coconut bread pudding or ice cream.

More

The Landing at Ocean Beach
The Landing at Ocean Beach
Reviews coming soon
Seafood | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

The Landing at Ocean Beach is the newest bay front, full service restaurant & bar in Ocean Beach. We offer brunch, lunch, and dinner seven days a week. More

Albatross
Albatross
Reviews coming soon
American | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Cafe Joelle
Cafe Joelle
Reviews coming soon
Fusion / Eclectic | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Café Joelle at Fire Island is a lovely restaurant with textured walls, pendant lighting, and neutral colors. The interior is welcoming and lovely in a charming, rustic, and inviting way. Seating lines either side of two adjacent walls and friendly waiters are always willing to provide you incredible service and a happy smile.

Foods that you should definitely try when you visit Café Joelle includes wasabi calamari, pasta with your choice of sauce, onion soup au gratin, chicken and shrimp vodka and grilled filet mignon. Whether you are looking for a romantic meal option or something you can enjoy with friends and family, Café Joelle is certainly the place to be.

More

Top of the Bay
Top of the Bay
(1)
American | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

A visit to this fine establishment is ALWAYS a special treat!!! The staff, food, and drinks are top notch! Do yourself a favor and treat yourself and your friends to a meal and drinks at Top of the Bay... you won't be disappointed:) More

OpenTable Diner -
The Bay Walk Cafe Limited
The Bay Walk Cafe Limited
Reviews coming soon
American | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Hideaway, The
Hideaway, The
Reviews coming soon
American | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

The Hideaway offers many seafood dishes in a cozy restaurant. Come with a partner for date night and sit out on the deck to watch the sunset over the water as you enjoy an entr�e of pan-seared scallops with lobster risotto or Jorge�s paella made up of lobster, mussels, clams, shrimp and chorizo. Relax with your favorite cocktail and snack on a plate of firecracker clams casino consisting of a half dozen clams served with fire roasted jalapeno peppers and smoked bacon for an unforgettable taste. The Hideaway also has vegan or vegetarian options such as veggies � la Grecque served with minted Greek yogurt.

The full bar at the Hideaway will make sure that no matter what you order, there is a drink that will pair well with the dish. Reservations can be made to ensure a seat is available upon arrival and are encouraged for dinner and on the weekends.

More

Le Dock
Le Dock
(119)
Seafood | Fire Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Loved the place. Wish there was more fine dining on dire island!! More

OpenTable Diner -