Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Port Jefferson

View all

Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Port Jefferson

Best Seafood Restaurants in Port Jefferson

View all

Best Seafood Restaurants in Port Jefferson

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Tavern on the Green
(2715)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
Sushi Yasaka
(954)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Spice it up: Explore Port Jefferson Restaurants.

Port Jefferson Restaurants

Fifth SeasonFifth Season
2083 reviews
Contemporary American | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Fifth Season is fantastic. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu and the service is great. The food is creative and very delicious. I have been there several times and each time has been terrific. I highly recommend Fifth Season, I'll be back! Thank you. More

OpenTable Diner -
Pasta PastaPasta Pasta
1410 reviews
Italian | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Great find in Port Jefferson, had the pleasure of being serviced by the owner. All around wonderful dining experience, definitely would recommend and be back . More

OpenTable Diner -
Ruvo EastRuvo East
1412 reviews
Italian | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Nice restaurant; however, not great. Food was good, but nothing extraordinary and the same to say about the whole experience. We did feel the service was rushed to turn over the table. Each step from drinks to desert was pushed along and didn’t leave us any wiggle room for conversation. Eat and get out was clearly implied by the server as the drink menu was given to us immediately and she returned moments later for the order, to bringing us a dinner menu with our drinks, to returning for our order several minutes late, to bringing our food out in record breaking time, to picking up our food the minute we placed a fork down, to dropping our check before dessert was over or we could order a cordial. Efficient service, but rushed. Also, be cautious because the happy our drink menu is given to you at your table, but those prices aren’t allowed at the table and only apply if you’re at the bar. More

OpenTable Diner -
Nantuckets Port JeffersonNantuckets Port Jefferson
125 reviews
Contemporary American | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Service was excellent. The owner stopped by and was very pleasant and friendly. Appetizers and entrees were well paced and presentation was very pleasing. One order had the wrong veggie and was changed out quickly and politely with an appropriate apology. We will definitely return and hopefully find parking in Port Jefferson. More

OpenTable Diner -
Carnival RestaurantCarnival Restaurant
107 reviews
American | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Great service, food and atmosphere . Have been here before and will definitely go again More

OpenTable Diner -
Wave Seafood & Steak at Danford's Hotel, Marina & SpaWave Seafood & Steak at Danford's Hotel, Marina & Spa
669 reviews
Seafood | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Pricy for what is served but food is good and excellent location/view with white linen service. More

OpenTable Diner -
Setauket Pita HouseSetauket Pita House
21 reviews
Mediterranean | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

We have been there many times before. On this night there was a three piece ensemble playing mellow music conducive to dining. The food was very good, as always and service was very attentive. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Waterview At Port Jeff Country ClubThe Waterview At Port Jeff Country Club
38 reviews
Global, International | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Our lunch experience was excellent. The service, food and atmosphere was perfect! More

OpenTable Diner -
Mr. P's Southern SkilletMr. P's Southern Skillet
2 reviews
Regional American (Southern) | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

After owning L.I Pour House Bar and Grill for four years, Anthony Pallino and Executive Chef Joseph Festinger knew that not only Port Jeff but the whole Island has been missing something special. Creating Mr.P's Southern Skillet together it features Live Music alongside 5 star cooking in a relaxing atmosphere.More

Port Jefferson Diners' Choice Winners

Port Jefferson's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Fifth SeasonFifth Season
2083 reviews
Contemporary American | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Fifth Season is fantastic. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu and the service is great. The food is creative and very delicious. I have been there several times and each time has been terrific. I highly recommend Fifth Season, I'll be back! Thank you. More

OpenTable Diner -
Pasta PastaPasta Pasta
1410 reviews
Italian | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Great find in Port Jefferson, had the pleasure of being serviced by the owner. All around wonderful dining experience, definitely would recommend and be back . More

OpenTable Diner -
Ruvo EastRuvo East
1412 reviews
Italian | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Nice restaurant; however, not great. Food was good, but nothing extraordinary and the same to say about the whole experience. We did feel the service was rushed to turn over the table. Each step from drinks to desert was pushed along and didn’t leave us any wiggle room for conversation. Eat and get out was clearly implied by the server as the drink menu was given to us immediately and she returned moments later for the order, to bringing us a dinner menu with our drinks, to returning for our order several minutes late, to bringing our food out in record breaking time, to picking up our food the minute we placed a fork down, to dropping our check before dessert was over or we could order a cordial. Efficient service, but rushed. Also, be cautious because the happy our drink menu is given to you at your table, but those prices aren’t allowed at the table and only apply if you’re at the bar. More

OpenTable Diner -
Nantuckets Port JeffersonNantuckets Port Jefferson
125 reviews
Contemporary American | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Service was excellent. The owner stopped by and was very pleasant and friendly. Appetizers and entrees were well paced and presentation was very pleasing. One order had the wrong veggie and was changed out quickly and politely with an appropriate apology. We will definitely return and hopefully find parking in Port Jefferson. More

OpenTable Diner -
Carnival RestaurantCarnival Restaurant
107 reviews
American | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Great service, food and atmosphere . Have been here before and will definitely go again More

OpenTable Diner -
Wave Seafood & Steak at Danford's Hotel, Marina & SpaWave Seafood & Steak at Danford's Hotel, Marina & Spa
669 reviews
Seafood | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Pricy for what is served but food is good and excellent location/view with white linen service. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Waterview At Port Jeff Country ClubThe Waterview At Port Jeff Country Club
38 reviews
Global, International | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

Our lunch experience was excellent. The service, food and atmosphere was perfect! More

OpenTable Diner -