1. Pasta Pasta
Italian | Port JeffersonBooked 13 times today
Very nice restaurant
2. Prohibition Kitchen
American | Port Jefferson
A little too fatty for me. Had difficulty finding food I could eat. Using donuts for bread is just a really bad idea. Pass on this one
3. Fifth Season
Contemporary American | Port JeffersonBooked 19 times today
We highly recommend this place for the ambiance and the food and cocktails. The prix fix menu was very reasonable. We will definitely be back to try another seasons menu.
4. Nantuckets Port Jefferson
Contemporary American | Port JeffersonBooked 14 times today
First time there. Food and service were exemplary.
5. The Waterview At Port Jeff Country Club
Global, International | Port JeffersonBooked 2 times today
Very friendly and attentive staff. Very good service. Food very good and plentiful. Was treated like a regular even though it was our first time.
6. Carnival Restaurant
American | Port JeffersonBooked 4 times today
I made a reservation for 9 people and they put us in the private dining area, so we had a more intimate and private meal.
7. Wave Seafood & Steak at Danford's Hotel, Marina & Spa
Seafood | Port JeffersonBooked 7 times today
We had a lovely dinner for my parents 60th anniversary. Excellent table with a harbor view, uncrowded, unrushed, excellent food, quality choices for vegetarians (yay!) and an attentive, accommodating server. A little pricey but it was well worth it. And I'll keep this on top of my list for the Port...
8. Margaritas Cafe - Port Jefferson Station
Mexican | Port JeffersonBooked 3 times today
My vegetarian choice of Poblano peppers was very disappointing. It was over filled with some sorts of greens and I couldn’t even taste the Poblano peppers!! I did point it out to Allen, the Manager. The Margaritas were excellent tonight. Brea, our waitress was wonderful. Thank you.