Diners' Choice: American restaurants in Indianapolis

OpenTable

Updated 05 October 2026

Looking for restaurants with the best overall American cuisine in Indianapolis? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyses more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favourites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Our Table | American Bistro

4.9

4.9 (2250)

$30 and under

American

Bargersville

About the restaurant

Our Table brings the food, service, and atmosphere to the south side that you have been craving. Chef Joe Miller and his team source the best ingredients and make all their offerings from scratch. They showcase their fresh ingredients using preparations that are simple, yet refined. Come to Our Table to experience fresh seafood flown in daily; delicious hand-made artisan flatbreads; signature beef tenderloin sliders; or a sizzling steak.

Top review

AaronGold

Dined 5 days ago

Quite possibly the most welcoming restaurant we have been to. On par with Hall's Chophouse in Charlestown, SC which is a high compliment in our book! Food was great especially the filet, the salads and they chicken velvet soup. Looking forward to our next visit!

Discover more

Popular dish

Beef Tenderloin Sliders (2)

Popular dish

Old World Lasagna

Popular dish

Shrimp Bucatini 'Diablo'

Adams Street Chophouse

4.8

4.8 (427)

$31 to $50

American

Muncie

About the restaurant

Step into a 1935 Chophouse, just east of "mid town," in Muncie, Indiana where a revamped old house welcomes you to Adams Street Chophouse. Open Tuesday to Saturday, our menu boasts USDA prime beef, hand-selected for an unparalleled dining experience.

All ages are welcome to savor the era of innovation and prohibition in our charming establishment. Explore four unique rooms—the 1920s Adams St. Room, the Frank Sinatra Room, the Rat Pack Room, and the exclusive Speakeasy (21+). Adams Street Chophouse seamlessly blends history and imagination, inviting you to a culinary journey through time in the old Thomas S. Neely house.

Join us at Adams Street Chophouse, where timeless charm meets exceptional dining.

Top review

Brian

Dined on 27 Oct 2026

Wonderful food! Great atmosphere! Must visit if in the Muncie area!

Discover more

Popular dish

Bone-In New York Strip

Garden Table - Mass Ave

4.8

4.8 (72)

$30 and under

American

Downtown Indy

About the restaurant

The Garden Table is a local eatery and fresh juicery with two Indianapolis locations. We serve seasonally influenced and locally sourced food and cold pressed juice. We believe in simple dishes, made from natural ingredients, grown and harvested by local farmers.

Top review

Justin

Dined on 2 Oct 2026

We stopped here for brunch before an event later in the day. Our reservation got us seated quickly. We were given a nice amount of time to look over the menu and not rushed into ordering. Price was good for the quality of food, drinks, and atmosphere. We would definitely choose to come back if we visit Indy in the future!

BRU Burger Bar - Brownsburg

4.9

4.9 (377)

$30 and under

American

Avon

About the restaurant

We are very excited to offer great burgers, beer, salads, and appetizers to the Brownsburg community. This location offers indoor dining, outdoor dining, and carryout.

Please be aware that we do not accept reservations for the patio.

We will hold reservations until 15 minutes past the reservation time before releasing. If you are running behind feel free to let us know and we may be able to adjust your reservation!

Top review

LoriGold

Dined on 26 Sept 2026

Excellent good, server Erin was very attentive, the salad was excellent though it was a bit more expensive than a normal salad I would get. They were running a little behind in the kitchen and the manager came by to tell us and thanked us for our patience. Things happen and we were very understanding. It was a nice touch to have the manager come by to talk with each table affected. We will back again!

Discover more

Experience

Happy Hour at BRU

Carnegie's A Place To Eat

4.8

4.8 (154)

$30 and under

American

Greenfield

About the restaurant

Set inside Greenfield’s historic Carnegie Library, Carnegie’s offers a timeless dining experience where history meets modern hospitality. Guests enjoy expertly crafted dishes, thoughtful wine and cocktail selections, and gracious service in one of Indiana’s most charming spaces. Perfect for date nights, anniversaries, gatherings upwards of 14 people, or the every day occasions, Carnegie’s blends regional dining with local warmth—never pretentious, always memorable. Whether you’re savoring a chef special or toasting to an occasion, every detail is designed to create an evening you’ll want to repeat. Discover why Carnegie’s is Greenfield’s destination for approachable dining.

Top review

RickGold

Dined on 23 Oct 2026

We always enjoy Carnegies. Especially the service via Jackie.

Courthouse Club

4.8

4.8 (592)

$30 and under

American

Noblesville

About the restaurant

Courthouse Club where culinary passion meets a warm and inviting atmosphere. Nestled on the northeast corner of The Square in Downtown Noblesville, our restaurant offers a delightful escape from the everyday hustle. Savor the flavors of our meticulously crafted dishes, each prepared with the freshest ingredients. Whether you're indulging in a romantic evening away, celebrating with friends, or enjoying a business meal with clients, our attentive staff and elegant ambiance ensure an unforgettable dining experience. Join us at Courthouse Club, where every visit is built on elevating personal connection.

Top review

Janelle

Dined on 15 Oct 2026

Excellent service and food. Seated next to the bar with live music which made it harder for the older people at our table to hear, but was a very nice ambiance.

Discover more

4.9

4.9 (1758)

$31 to $50

American

Anderson

About the restaurant

An Indiana legend since 1934, Bonge’s Tavern is a one-of-a-kind dining experience where small-town charm meets unforgettable food. Known for its eclectic menu, signature cocktails, and iconic tailgate tradition, Bonge’s draws guests from across the Midwest for nights filled with flavor, laughter, and community spirit. Inside, you’ll find an intimate, nostalgic atmosphere paired with creative, chef-driven dishes that keep regulars returning decade after decade. Whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth, Bonge’s delivers the same warmth, energy, and authenticity that made it famous. Come for the food—stay for the experience.

Guests may tailgate prior to their reservation. Please check-in with the hostess by coming to the front porch entrance to let us know you have arrived for the evening. Tailgating is for individuals 21+. Individuals at the minimum age of 18 must be accompanied by a parent/guardian. Dining is limited to 1 1/2-2 HRS depending on party size.

Top review

Christa

Dined 7 days ago

One of my all time favorite places to treat myself and family for a wondeful dinner. Service is always great, food is always amazing!

Discover more

Applewood Smoked Pork Chop

Tinker Street

4.8

4.8 (480)

$31 to $50

American

Downtown Indy

About the restaurant

Tinker Street, which serves guests 21 and older, has array of wine offerings be it red, white, sparking and everything in between.
Nestled in Herron-Morton Place, a historic neighborhood adjacent to the Old Northside Historic District, Tinker Street is a nod to 16th Street’s name during the dirt-road days of the 1800s. Today, it’s a seven-dollar Uber ride from downtown hotels, a pleasant stroll for neighbors, and a convenient drive from most parts of town.
The dinner menu changes seasonally to capture the flavors of fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Vegan, vegetarian and gluten-free options are abundant–and clearly marked on the menu.

Top review

Justin

Dined on 23 Oct 2026

I love Tinker Street - great food and vibes, and excellent service! Highly recommend!

Freeland's at North End

4.8

4.8 (271)

$31 to $50

American

Carmel

About the restaurant

Exquisite Refined Dining with a focus on seasonal cuisine served in a warm and inviting setting.
A Hidden Gem in Carmel, Indiana.

Head Chef: Braedon Kellner

Top review

Kelly

Dined 5 days ago

Great experience, exceptional food, excellent staff. Our new favorite place!

bar ellis

4.8

4.8 (534)

$30 and under

American

Noblesville

About the restaurant

bar ellis or BE as we like to call it- is open for dinner, late night bites, drinks, and live entertainment! We have created a delicious menu with classic comfort food, offering options from appetizers and sandwiches to steaks and seafood! And of course, our delicious desserts all made in house from scratch! bar ellis has something for everyone, including a thoughtfully curated vegetarian and vegan menu along with signature cocktails and mocktails! We feature local musicians every Saturday Night and Karaoke every Friday Night from 9PM-MID! No reservations are required for these events as it is open seating. bar ellis is home to two bars, a rooftop patio, and an outdoor alley for seasonal seating! All within a cozy, two story, historic building on the square in downtown Noblesville!

Top review

SherrellGold

Dined 7 days ago

Loved enjoying dinner on the patio upstairs! Food and drink were delicious! Service was excellent!

Explore Diners' Choice best of Indianapolis

Explore more Diners' Choice lists