From our Zagat Review "Best Red Sauce East of the City"
We look forward to serving you many more meals Buon Appetit!
Great food and fantastic service. Real old school.
Exceptionally pleased with everything, service, staff and their personalities,ambience, and the food is marvelous! Perfect spot for our 51st. Anniversary dinner which was the day of our reservation. We’ve already recommended your establishment to others and especially to our daughter who will be celebrating her Wedding Anniversary in August. My husband and I have been to many of the highly rated New York Italian Restaurants and yours most definitely up there with them all. Just sorry it took us so many years to dine with you.
Eric(Ricky) & Susan Schwartz
Best place to spend a birthday !!!
Everything is always good!
Delicious authentic Italian cuisine and wonderful service. We had a relaxing evening!
Always delicious. Specials exceptional Wait staff knowledgeable friendly and great
May I make a suggestion to perhaps have a written list if the extensive specials dishes.
Our servers, Eddie and Guillermo were efficient, quick and above all, very personable. We’ve been back to Trattoria DiMeo numerous times over a number of years and I’ve got to say that the chef/owner, Sal, serves up perfect Italian fare night after night. I had the most basic item on the menu, penne and meatballs which had a delicious sauce which I loved. I truly recommend a visit very soon.
Great service and an amazing recitation of the complex Mother's Day specials! The food was superb and we felt well pampered throughout. Also nice to see Cabernet Franc - the local specialty - on the menu after a day exploring the North Fork wineries!
Mother's Day at Trottoria DiMeo was wonderful. My wife loves this restaurant, and they delivered!
Very prompt in seating us. Food and service was very good.
Sincerely, always the best in terms of ambiance, service and food.
Excellent Italian food! We have lived in this area for almost 30 years, and had never been here before. So sorry we have been missing out all these years! So good! Will be back!
Excellent food and service. Terrific restaurant
Really fabulous restaurant. Only minus is that there is no bathroom on the main level therefore not conducive to handicap clients. Other than that, I would go back all the time.
Wonderful dinner as always, thank you!
Always love dining with you!
The food and service are always tops!!
Exceptional food and service. Everything was perfect from the drinks to the dessert. A must try and will definitely go back again soon.
Always great meal!
Food good, shrimp parm seemed a little smaller than usual for some reason and the flourless cake was a little dry. Everything else was very tasty
This is an excellent restaurant, across the board - food is superb, with an excellent red sauce- service and overall ambiance is tops, and even the bar is gorgeous and comfortable- my husband and I have become regulars !!
We went all out. Appetizer, soup, salad and delicious entrees. Everything was very tasty ! The service was top notch!
It would be nice to see people get a little more dressed up for this well decorated restaurant.
Consistent delicious food and amazing service
Good food in a very nice room. The staff was helpful and caring! Happily we could have a conversation!! We will definitely be back!!
Just love it here and continue to come back time after time, thank you!
Waiter has a attitude.. when we asked where our drinks were we were told that she’s busy and when there ready we will get our drinks .. no way to answer customers
Small but mighty ... mighty delicious, mighty good menu selections, mighty wonderful wine choices, mighty fabulous service staff, mighty busy. Reservations a must ...
Consistently delicious. I definitely recommend wholeheartedly.
The food at Trattoria DiMeo is always consistent and I know it’s always fresh and delicious.. nobody makes the deserts better especially the cream brûlée with Nutella
There was 4 of us. And each appetizer and dinner was better than the nexy
Great dinner- a favorite for 48 years. Love the menu and my salmon was excellent. Everyone loved their entree.
Usually food is good service could be better .. management very happy to satisfy very nice
Wonderful dining experience with delicious food and attentive service. Truly defines neighborhood gem.
We had an amazing meal last night. I had the branzino and seafood over linguini zucchini. My friend had one of the night's special which was seafood crusted halibut (I hope I said that correctly). In both cases we left clean plates. Delicate flavors, not salty out of this world delicious. First class service. Great menu selections all at a fair price.
Very pleasant atmosphere. Excell my service Food ok but not great.
Food was amazing as always!
Excellent Italian food with outstanding service. The attention to detail by an accommodating staff was definitely a highlight. I liked the room with the fireplace in it.
Food was delicious and the service was so nice. Very generous wine pours too and they give you delicious biscotti after dinner for free. So nice!
I’ve been going for years to Dimeos food is alway excellent !! Top notch
Service is outstanding we always recommended this restaurant to our friends and family