Best American Restaurants in Fishers Island
Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating options
Award-winning
Accessibility
979 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
Booked 3 times today
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- PPeterNew York City •14 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoMarvelous! Service, food, ambience were fabulous. Always a pleasure to visit Oheka Castle.More infoOHK Bar & Restaurant$$$$• American• Huntington•4.6
- LlarryGoldNew York City •13 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoFirst time here. Excellent experience. Can’t wait to go backMore info317 Main Street$$$$• Gastro Pub• Farmingdale•4.7
- GGinaNew York City •5 reviews5.0Dined 4 days ago Our servers were fantastic. Brianna N and Brianna C. the charcuterie board was great super fresh and beautiful. The heritage chicken is my absolute favorite!!! I keep coming back for it specifically. Then for dessert the Dubai Chocolate Bar special was great. Best way to end the night!More infoThe Halston$$$$• American• Melville•4.7
- DDavidNew York City •7 reviews4.0Dined on 17 Oct 2026It really has the top of the line food. It is a bar and small and tight but it is not bar food, not at all.More infoThe Villager Farmingdale$$$$• American• Farmingdale•4.3
- Jjp1160New York City •6 reviews5.0Dined on 11 Oct 2026We took our daughter for brunch. The atmosphere was great. The food was great. DJ Stevie Styles was awesome. Our waiter Achilles was amazing. He was very fun, attentive, friendly and personable. He made our day. I would definitely come back for dinner and ask to sit in his section. He was fantastic!More infoHARLEYS American Grille$$$$• American• Farmingdale•4.7