Shelter Island Restaurants
Make a free booking
Book for breakfast today in New York State
OpenTable Icons
Book this year’s award-winners, hot newcomers, and hard-to-get tables.
Book this year’s award-winners, hot newcomers, and hard-to-get tables.
Find the right table in Shelter Island
Find the right table in Shelter Island
Let OpenTable find the best spots for you.
Powered by AI
Check out diners' favourite restaurants in Shelter Island
Updated on
Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.
The Chequit Restaurant
$$$$•Italian•4.7(50)The Chequit Restaurant + Bar brings warm, approachable Italian dining to one of Shelter Island’s most iconic hotel destinations.
Set inside The Chequit, the restaurant is intimate, coastal, and quietly seductive — a place for golden-hour cocktails, handmade Italian flavors, candlelit dinners, and long island evenings that feel effortless. As Shelter Island’s only Italian restaurant, and Shelter Island's only stand up bar, The Chequit offers a dining experience that is refined without feeling formal, stylish without trying too hard, and rooted in the kind of hospitality that makes guests want to stay a little longer.
Join us for coastal Italian dishes, crafted cocktails, thoughtful wines, and the timeless charm of The Chequit Hotel.
Dinner reservations available from 5 PM–8:30 PM Thursday - Saturday. Bar open from 4 PM.SALT Shelter Island
$$$$•Seafood•4.6(226)The story of SALT started with Keith and Ali's love for Shelter Island. SALT was designed as a come as you are restaurant with a focus on fresh and local foods, that anyone can enjoy. They wanted to create a place they would want to go for dinner or drinks and find friendly service from other people who live and love Shelter Island. We treat locals like celebrities and celebrities like locals!
Outdoor dining in New York State
See what locals rave about in Shelter Island
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- JJohnNew York City •3 reviews5.0Dined 7 days agoWe celebrated our 20th wedding anniversary and it was amazing! Every member of the staff wished us a special day and we felt well taken care of. The food was delicious. Thank you for a great experience!More infoThe North Fork Table & Inn$$$$• Contemporary American• Southold•4.7
- JJonNew York City •11 reviews5.0Dined on 15 Oct 2026Excellent drinks and dinner menu. Not too expensive, and the service and food quality are top level. I highly recommend the crab cakes, scallops, filet minon sliders.More infoNoah's$$$$• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.5
- CChristineNew York City •1 review4.0Dined on 15 Oct 2026Beautiful view for a sunset meal. The staff were friendly and welcoming. The food was delicious. Overall a positive experience.More infoThe Halyard Restaurant at Sound View$$$$• American• Greenport•4.2
- SScottNew York City •4 reviews5.0Dined on 9 Oct 2026Excellent knowledgeable server. Excellent taste and experience.More infoVine Street Cafe$$$$• American• Shelter Island•4.7
- TTerriGoldNew York City •23 reviews5.0Dined on 26 Sept 2026Always a delicious meal and great service. Never disappoints!More infoPort Waterfront Bar and Grill$$$$• Bar / Lounge / Bottle Service• Greenport•4.4
Trending dishes in Shelter Island
Explore dishes that diners are raving about
Restaurant experiences trending in New York State
Private Dining
Find the perfect place for your next party or group dining event.
Explore private diningPrivate Dining
Find the perfect place for your next party or group dining event.
Frequently asked questions
The best reviewed restaurant in Shelter Island is The Chequit Restaurant
The best vegan restaurants in Shelter Island are SALT Shelter Island, The Terrace at the Pridwin and Vine Street Cafe
The best vegetarian restaurants in Shelter Island are Vine Street Cafe, The Terrace at the Pridwin and SALT Shelter Island
The restaurants with the best service in Shelter Island are The Chequit Restaurant, SALT Shelter Island and Vine Street Cafe
The restaurants with the best ambiance in Shelter Island are SALT Shelter Island, The Terrace at the Pridwin and The Chequit Restaurant
Explore OpenTable
- Home
- United States
- New York State